Why the US has birthright citizenship
2,336,446 views 4 months ago
Americans don’t agree on whether being born here should make you a citizen. That’s not new. Support our work. Become a Vox Member today: http://www.vox.com/memberships On the first day of Donald Trump’s second presidential term, he signed an executive order about an old American rule: that with very few exceptions, anyone born here is a citizen. Trump’s order stated that the rule, which comes from the 14th Amendment to the Constitution, should no longer apply to the children of those in the United States illegally or temporarily. Within a few weeks that order had been blocked by multiple federal judges — but it was a temporary resolution, with the ultimate outcome yet to be determined, probably by the Supreme Court. The US is far from the only country in the world that offers unconditional birthright citizenship. While it’s uncommon in Europe, Asia, and Africa, it’s very common among Western Hemisphere countries, partly because of their history as colonies populated mostly by settlers. But of the many countries with birthright citizenship in the world, the US is by far the largest, with hundreds of thousands of baby citizens born here every year to noncitizen parents. Those numbers naturally raise the question: Is this what birthright citizenship was meant for? And why do we have birthright citizenship in the first place? The short answer is that birthright citizenship in the US came about as a way of granting citizenship after the American Civil War to the large population of formerly enslaved Black people. But that raises a different question: How did a law intended for Black Americans end up creating hundreds of thousands of new US citizens born to immigrant parents every year? In this video we trace that history, answer that question, and look at a few of the times that the US has actually had this argument before. Today’s concerns over birthright citizenship may feel specific to our particular immigration debate. They’re actually not. 00:00 A rule 2:23 Jus soli 3:13 Dred Scott 4:46 The 14th Amendment 8:02 Wong Kim Ark 10:30 Another look at the 14th Amendment Sources and further reading: Garrett Epps’s law review article about the citizenship clause of the 14th Amendment has everything you’ll ever need to know about the history of birthright citizenship in the US: https://digitalcommons.wcl.american.e... The Library of Congress has a great map showing which countries of the world offer unconditional birthright citizenship like the US: https://maint.loc.gov/law/help/birthr... The 1861 map of the US we use a few times in the piece is itself a strikingly rich document that I could stare at forever: https://www.loc.gov/resource/g3701sm.... Some other original documents we use in the piece: Trump’s executive order on birthright citizenship: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/F... The Ipsos poll containing the question about support for ending birthright citizenship for children of undocumented immigrants: https://static01.nyt.com/newsgraphics... The Dred Scott decision: https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services... President Andrew Johnson’s letter vetoing the 1866 Civil Rights Act: https://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/docum... Congress’s debates over the 14th Amendment (we quoted from page 498): https://www.congress.gov/congressiona... The 1882 Chinese Exclusion Act: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/S... The Wong Kim Ark decision: https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services... Subscribe to our channel! http://goo.gl/0bsAjO Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out http://www.vox.com. Watch our full video catalog: http://goo.gl/IZONyE Follow Vox on Facebook: http://goo.gl/U2g06o Or Twitter: http://goo.gl/XFrZ5H

Shorts

Our most recent videos, plus topics in the news today.

Are probiotics in yogurt a gimmick?

Vox
323K views1 month ago

Why this red state made preschool free

Vox
491K views2 months ago

No, honey can’t cure your allergies

Vox
194K views3 months ago
Vox goes beyond headlines and horse-race coverage to explain what matters in politics. We bring context and clarity to political decisions and demystify the policies that shape the country.

Why this red state made preschool free

Vox
491K views2 months ago

Why the US has birthright citizenship

Vox
2.3M views4 months ago

What polls can actually tell us

Vox
670K views8 months ago

Exactly how Trump could ban abortion

Vox
868K views10 months ago
The Gray Area is a Vox podcast that takes a philosophy-minded look at culture, technology, politics, and the world of ideas. Each week, we invite a guest to explore a question or topic that matters. From the state of democracy, to the struggle with depression and anxiety, to the nature of identity in the digital age, each episode looks for nuance and honesty. For full episodes, check out The Gray Area at https://www.vox.com/the-gray-area or wherever you get your podcasts.
It seems like AI is taking over the world — but how does it actually work and what does it struggle with? From language models like ChatGPT to AI in the World Cup, here are our videos on the robot revolution.

Can clean energy handle the AI boom?

Vox
298K views9 months ago

How AI could help us talk to animals

Vox
1.2M views11 months ago

The evolution of the movie backdrop

Vox
325K views1 year ago

AI art, explained

Vox
2.5M views3 years ago
From the rise and fall of economies to the fight to preserve democracies, we explain the ripple effects of events and movements that impact billions across the globe.
Vox explains our changing planet with a focus on sustainability. The battle to slow climate change is daunting but we bring you the hopeful experiments and unexpected victories that show progress is possible.
Helping people live better lives individually and collectively — from mental health to relationships of all kinds to work, money, and more.

The lies that sell fast fashion

Vox
826K views1 year ago

Why everything you buy is worse now

Vox
4.7M views2 years ago
Stories about the world’s problems — problems that are big and neglected, and that most people don’t hear about nearly often enough — and the solutions that could fix them.
We cut through the clutter of personal finance explainers to answer big questions many of us have about our money: Should I rent or should I buy to build wealth in the US? How do credit card rewards work behind the scenes? And why is everything so expensive?